Carolyn thought her biggest worry was to successfully deliver the chalice to where it belongs, but soon a new obstacle presents itself. Though a strong relationship develops between Caro and the Colonel, John, she can't help but feel that maybe her likeness to Gabriella might have something to do with it. Not only that, but on their journey to return the chalice they soon discover stories about Gabriella's past, to John's dismay. And as though to add salt to the wound, Caro also has a devastating past that presents itself in the form of a letter addressed to John. After learning about Gabriella's past actions, John couldn't help but feel judgmental towards Caro and not even give her a chance to explain. Caro knew she couldn't trust in love, but she thought John was different. Will all be resolved in the end?