What they got right: Right from the first page, where Sam makes dinner for the narrator he's taken over for (and regrets what he served), the hilarity flows off the page. It's the right balance of story and jokes. Randolph really knows how to use the characters in this story, even more than Beedle did in Muppet Robin Hood. The art is so beautiful that I had to track down Amy Mebberson's site (because every idiot on Earth has one–for example: me). Apparently she has two (and a Deviant Art and Flickr page). She is an awesome artist, and just perfect for this comic. (If you haven't noticed, I'm becoming a fan.)
What they got wrong: Why are Sam's word balloons done with dashed lines? In normal comic stylings, this means he has laryngitis.
Recommendation: Pick this comic up and prepare to fall in love.