What they got right: Chat.
What else they got right: I'm not sure what Cloak and Dagger have been doing in the Marvel Universe these days, and I never really followed them, so this would be my first non-cover exposure to the characters. I think they're used pretty well, and Chat (a Tobin original for this series) actually has a backstory beyond being a mutant who talks to animals. Stacy is a believable character, and I hope he becomes what Spidey has needed for a long time (outside of the marriage-that-no-longer-ever-happened), a confidant. I also hope Chat ends up fulfilling that role. I just love Ch…wait, is that a cameo by Det. Lee, one of my favorite characters from the 90's Fox cartoon? I hope so.
What they got wrong: Um…not putting Tobin on this title sooner?
Recommendation: Any chance of getting Chat and Tobin's Tigra in a story together? "Chat Loves Spider-Man"?