Cross and Wendy's quest to find John and Michael hits a snag when the two are separated during their battle with the islands natives. Wendy and Dr. Harlow are taken prisoner with little hope of rescue before they are burned at the stake. Unfortunately Cross is in even worse shape as he falls under the spell of one of Neverland's most sinister Siren's. Before they have any chance of saving the boys our heroes are going to have to find a way to save themselves first.